Over the course of one month, we’ve spent about 20 hours on research, expert interviews, and hands-on testing. Through our evaluation on some of the top automatic cigarette rollers, the Top-O-Matic Cigarette Rolling Machine stood out among the rest. We are impressed by its simplistic and sturdy design which packs the right amount of tobacco in almost all of the empty tubes we’ve tested it on. The cigarette roller is manufactured to fill 100 mm tubes and king sizes, so it’s hard not to like this gadget. Comparing to the store bought cigarettes from the gas station, this device can save you money and even pay for itself after a month.

Do you ever wish that you could find another way to make cigarettes?

The cost of store bought cigarettes are skyrocketing and you feel like there’s nothing else you can do but empty your pockets. The price hikes of cigarettes are all over the news and you can’t seem to find an alternative solution other than to go with the flow.

Frustrating, isn’t it?

Here's a little secret on how you can save your money -- automatic cigarette rollers.

We’ve conducted tons of research and hands-on tests on automatic cigarette rollers and we’ve learned a lot about them throughout the process.

There are essentially two different kinds out there- electric and manual cigarette rolling machines. We took the liberty to study the difference between the two and made sure to look at all the necessary things that would help in determining which one’s the best.

Regarding the how’s and why’s of the matter, this post will tell you all the things we did to determine our top pick among all 5.

So what are you waiting for?

Let’s start.

The Best Automatic Cigarette Rollers 2018

Pain Relief GelOunceActive IngredientsAge
Biofreeze Professional Pain Relieving Gel4 ouncesMentholMay be used by children  2 years and adults
Sombra Cool Therapy Natural Pain Relieving Gel 8 oz8 ouncesMentholMay be used by children  2 years and adults
Glucosamine Pain Relief Gel9 ounceCapsicum Oleoresin
Adults 18 years and older
Dr. Pat’s Muscle Pain Relief Topical Analgesic Gel16 ouncesMentholMay be used by children  2 years and adults
Mineral Ice Therapeutic Pain Relieving Gel, 16 Ounce Jar16 ouncesMentholMay be used by children  2 years and adults

How Do Automatic Cigarette Rollers Work?

Automatic cigarette rollers are small and compact. It works by adding tobacco evenly to the tobacco’s compartment and placing a cigarette tube on the end nozzle. You can start the machine by either pulling a lever or pushing a button. Engaging the machine will then insert the tobacco into the cigarette tube.

There are also non-electric cigarette rollers which work by adding a roller paper (make sure to moisten the edge) into a compartment then snugly putting in bits of the tobacco at the bottom of that compartment. Closing the lid will automatically roll the paper with the tobacco in it and produce the cigarette out of the top lid.

If your goal is to make lots of cigarettes quickly on a regular basis, automatic cigarette rollers may be the right fit for you.

Ultimate Buyer's Guide

There are a lot of different types of cigarette rolling machines in the market. But most of them, more or less, function the same way. But there are a few things to take into consideration before choosing your roller.

Some of the common concerns people face with automatic cigarette rollers are the empty spaces before the filter or how it’s not packed tight enough. Some even experience their cigarette tubes tearing and not staying on the machine’s nozzle during the installation.

So here are few things we’ve compiled for you to consider to avoid the unwanted scenarios above. 

1. Budget

You might want to consider automatic cigarette rollers as a good investment considering the current costs of cigarettes. You’re likely to spend relatively less with these machines. It is, however, also important to follow your budget. That is, get the best machine based on your funds.

It does not necessarily mean choosing the machine that has the most features or getting the most expensive in the market. It simply means getting one that won’t just break in a matter of weeks or months. 

2. Quality

Find one that requires minimal maintenance and has an easy cleaning process. Sometimes jams occur only because of tobacco powder building up on the chamber so that’s nothing to be scared about- if you read reviews about jams, chances are, their machines just needed a little bit of cleaning so look for other telltale signs that indicate bad quality products like feedbacks about levers breaking or low quality materials being used in the machine.

3. Control

How much control do you want to have on your machine? Some cigarette rollers have metal constructed handles which provides you with additional stability for manual rolling. But most of the electric rollers have these essential features: 

  • Speed control – Some have switches for speed control that allows you to set how quickly you can roll a cigarette.
  • Forward and reverse - Others have forward and reverse switches that lets you fix jammed tobacco in the nozzle by vacuuming the stuck pieces in the nozzle back into the tobacco compartment
  • Density setting – There are also machines capable of setting the density of how much tobacco you want to pack in a single tube of cigarette.

How We Assessed and Evaluated These Products

We swept through the whole state in search for local cigarette shops. We made it a point to visit the most popular ones so that we won’t miss out on any of available cigarette rollers.

We were not at all surprised at how many we found (about 30 different kinds) because we expected that there were a lot of automatic cigarette rollers we can choose.

A specialized team was then formed to assess all of the cigarette rollers we’ve found. We began by noting all the information, features and characteristics that we deemed were vital on each of them. We then itemized the common buying criteria by conducting surveys and gathering crowd-sourced opinions.

After the criteria and researching the quality, performance, feedback on each of the rollers, we narrowed the list down by eliminating those we think are substandard cigarette rollers. We scored each of the remaining ones on the list.

We then went and grabbed the top 5 automatic cigarette rollers and placed them through a series of tests in our headquarter, each of which was intended to evaluate the top contenders. 

Throughout the process of reviewing and product testing, we made sure there was strictly no incentive from the brands, manufacturers, or vendors that would, in any way, affect our opinions on the products. 

Our Top Picks

The Powermatic 2 PLUS Electric Cigarette Injector Machine is one of the popular models in the market. It is basically a spoon fed electric cigarette injector machine that is capable of injecting tobacco in king-sized and 100mm -sized tubes.

From our hands-on testing, we discovered that this machine filled the tubes in approximately 2 seconds. Its motor will only run upon filling the tube. We also loved that the noise it makes was fairly minimal.

Upon evaluating how well it fills 100mm tubes, we’ve determined that you have to add a little more tobacco to each end and at the middle of the tube. It took a while to get used to it but, after a few tries, it became easier to gauge the amount of tobacco needed.

The injector nozzle on this machine is long enough to fill 100mm tubes, but we found that you have to give it a little push after each fill to get the tobacco packed to the end of the filter.

Kings are relatively easier to make. We were able to determine that it takes about 1 and a half teaspoon of tobacco to fill a king size cigarette. We have rolled about 20 Kings in a matter of 20 minutes, and we were quite impressed.

What We Liked

  • Injector motor sounded strong, smooth, and quiet 
  • Machine was sturdy and solid
  • Easily packed a 100 mm and King tube

What We Didn't Like

  • Some people have reported that the injector nozzle on their machines broke after a few tries
  • exclamation-triangle
    It took a few tries to learn how to properly fill the tubes all the way

Most of us were pretty new at this roll-your-own-cigarette concept and the All In One Automatic Cigarette Roller & Storage Box, made us smile every time a little cigarette pops out of its lid because it looked like magic. Just open the box, put the paper in place, add the tobacco, close the lid, and then pop! A cigarette emerges.

We found that this little portable device made rolling cigarettes easier, faster, and stress-free in comparison to the other products we reviewed. We loved that it packs tight cigarettes and that the below compartment is very handy for catching loose tobacco. It is also big enough to store extra tobacco and rolling papers.

We came across some difficulty in finding the right size of paper to use since it is marginally smaller. We have determined that this accepts up to 70mm paper only. But when we tested it, the machine worked with and without filters, so that gave it a lot of points in our book.

To make up for the short length, we found that it rolls fat cigarettes just like how it used to be in the 1920’s. 

What We Liked

  • Portable and small 
  • Instructions on how to use the device were easy to understand and concise
  • plus
    Doubled as a tobacco and paper storage

What We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Others found it difficult to make a roll
  • exclamation-triangle
    Some people reported that this made thinner than normal cigarettes

When we tried the PoweRoll by TOP-O-Matic Electric Cigarette Machine, we found that it makes solid and consistent king size cigarette tubes. We loved how this comes with its own chamber guard, protective case, tamper and a cleaning kit.

Although it will only make king size cigarettes, we think that it makes quality cigarettes- twice as good as the other contenders. It doesn’t crush the tobacco so there won’t be any problems about the embers at the end of the cigarette falling off in the middle of a smoke.

We were able to make about 70 cigarettes in 1 hour and encountered very minimal jams (around two) . We also figured that when it was jammed, it’s better not to force it by trying to roll another cigarette. It’s best to switch it on with the tobacco chamber door open. This technique pushes out the jam and avoids scratching the injector and tobacco chamber.

What We Liked

  • Came with its own carrying case 
  • We were able to clean it easily

What We Didn't Like

  • Cigarette came loose on the first few tries
  • exclamation-triangle
    Overfilling it caused it to jam

As the smallest device in the Powermatic family, we believe that this device makes a decent cigarette. We found that its small and compact design are making it easy to take with you wherever you need to go.

From the feedback we received, we noticed that people usually purchase two cigarette rollers – one to use and the other for back-up. We think that Powermatic Mini Cigarette Injector can also be a good alternative as a back-up as it is used as your main or primary cigarette roller machine. It is most useful during outages.

When we tried rolling cigarettes with this device, we were able to make about 40 100mm cigarettes before getting a jam. It was, however, because we accidentally stuffed too much tobacco in the chamber.

We also observed that as we made more cigarettes, the tobacco tended to build up in the filter- it’s noticeable when the lever becomes stuck. So we cleaned it with the tools that came along with the device. We thought it’s better to use a filter before filling the tobacco chamber to avoid getting unwanted buildup. 

What We Liked

  • Compact and portable, was easy to take when we were on the go 
  • Was consistent in packing tobacco all the way to the filter

What We Didn't Like

  • Needed a lot of arm strength to make more cigarettes- some women reported their arms getting sore
  • exclamation-triangle
    It was hard to figure out how to get the slider unstuck for some people

5. Top-O-Matic Cigarette Rolling Machine – Editor’s Choice

Throughout our product testing and evaluation, we considered many different factors when comparing each of the five automatic cigarette rollers. But the most important factor of all is how well each could roll a cigarette. We believe that the Top-O-Matic Cigarette Rolling Machine does the job really well.

We noticed that it was impossible to over-stuff this device since its tobacco chamber only had enough to fill 1 tube of cigarette. We also observed that you could clean the machine by taking the rubber mat off the bottom then cycling the lever a few times. After that, flip the machine upside down then cycle the lever again a few more times- this removes the fine tobacco dust that has accumulated inside the roller. This is a good thing because it mean that we could easily restore the machine back to normal.

We also found out that it’s better to use smooth tobacco. Regular pipe tobacco is too large and coarse causing the machine to jam up. It is also important to keep in mind to dry your tobacco before rolling it. Otherwise, it will stick and create a whole bunch of problems.

What We Liked

  • Heavy, well-built and was very easy to use 
  • This machine did not rip apart the cigarette tubes

What We Didn't Like

  • Made a lot of mess
  • exclamation-triangle
    Others have reported that it didn’t pack all the way to the filter

Our Recommendations:

Editor's Pick: This machine did not rip apart the cigarette tubes

Choosing the best automatic cigarette roller was difficult. All five of the cigarette rollers we tested were capable of rolling a perfectly packed cigarette. Ultimately, our decision was tied down to a few tie-breaker factors: how efficient the rollers packed a cigarette, how sturdy the machine is, and how quickly it could make one carton of cigarettes.

If we were to choose one ourselves, we’d go for the Top-O-Matic Cigarette Rolling Machine. With its well-built and robust cigarette injector, it can easily and evenly pack a cigarette tube. We loved that it’s fairly easy to use as well. All you need to do is just slip a tube on the injector, put your tobacco of choice in the tobacco chamber, set the size, and then pull the lever. And that’s it.

1st Runner Up: Powermatic 2 PLUS Electric Cigarette Injector Machine

This device came really close to Top-O-Matic is the Powermatic 2 PLUS Electric Cigarette Injector Machine. It’s a spoon fed injector machine, and in our opinion, it gives out a decent cigarette in seconds.

2nd Runner Up: Powermatic Mini Cigarette Injector

This is our third pick because of its well-built and compact design. We believe that it’s a perfect go-to device when you are traveling a lot. It’s sturdy enough to pack a good cigarette and it also makes minimal mess while rolling. It’s also a great backup machine with its reliable compression mechanism. If you live in an area with a lot of power outages, this one is a pretty decent thing to have if you are relying on an electric cigarette roller.